Most startups face two real alternatives. Here's how each compares.
Hiring In-House
BlackKatla
DIY Stack
What It Is
One senior security hire, plus tools and team you build out
A complete cybersecurity department on retainer
Vanta + fractional CISO + managed SOC + EDR + CSPM, stitched together
Annual Cost
$500K–$750K+ for a real function
$144K+ (from $12K/month, scope-dependent)
$170K–$400K depending on choices
Time to Audit-Ready
6–12 months from hire date
90 days from kickoff
6–12 months coordinating vendors
Vendors to Manage
One team to recruit, manage, and retain
One team. Us.
4–5 vendors, your CTO coordinates
Developer Time
Some pull-in for audit walkthroughs and technical evidence — your hire takes the rest
Some pull-in for technical walkthroughs — we handle questionnaires, auditor management, customer security calls
Still significantly pulled. The tools don't answer questionnaires; the fractional CISO doesn't have the bandwidth.
Accountability
Sits with your hire — until they leave
One team owns the outcome
Diffused. Each vendor blames the next.
Coverage
All seven functions, business hours. 24/7 means hiring 4+ more people.
All seven functions. 24/7 monitoring included.
Whatever your stack covers. 24/7 means adding another vendor on top.
Hidden Costs
Recruiting, equity, churn, ramp time
None. The price is the price.
Your CTO's time managing five vendors
BlackKatla
What It IsA complete cybersecurity department on retainer
Annual Cost$144K+ (from $12K/month, scope-dependent)
Time to Audit-Ready90 days from kickoff
Vendors to ManageOne team. Us.
Developer TimeSome pull-in for technical walkthroughs — we handle questionnaires, auditor management, customer security calls
AccountabilityOne team owns the outcome
CoverageAll seven functions. 24/7 monitoring included.
Hidden CostsNone. The price is the price.
Hiring In-House
What It IsOne senior security hire, plus tools and team you build out
Annual Cost$500K–$750K+ for a real function
Time to Audit-Ready6–12 months from hire date
Vendors to ManageOne team to recruit, manage, and retain
Developer TimeSome pull-in for audit walkthroughs and technical evidence — your hire takes the rest
AccountabilitySits with your hire — until they leave
CoverageAll seven functions, business hours. 24/7 means hiring 4+ more people.
Hidden CostsRecruiting, equity, churn, ramp time
DIY Stack
What It IsVanta + fractional CISO + managed SOC + EDR + CSPM, stitched together
Annual Cost$170K–$400K depending on choices
Time to Audit-Ready6–12 months coordinating vendors
Vendors to Manage4–5 vendors, your CTO coordinates
Developer TimeStill significantly pulled. The tools don't answer questionnaires; the fractional CISO doesn't have the bandwidth.
AccountabilityDiffused. Each vendor blames the next.
CoverageWhatever your stack covers. 24/7 means adding another vendor on top.
Hidden CostsYour CTO's time managing five vendors